Capital Ship Combat, part 4
Fighting on the Broadside
I’ve been taken to task a few times for my description of ships fighting along the broadside, so I want to defend that scenario. This particular entry presupposes you have at least a handful of direct-firing weapons. If your ship mounts only guided missiles — which can launch from any side of the ship and still reach their target — discussion of weapon arcs becomes irrelevant.
I’d like to start by defining the most important term: broadside. When the word “broadside” is used, it often conjures up an image of archaic sailing ships blasting away with fixed cannons that line the port and starboard. It’s a compelling image, but I think it also prejudices us a bit.
When referring to naval weapons, a broadside is not the port or starboard of the ship; it’s any length of the ship that mounts weapons. In classical, naval warfare, ships were long and narrow so they could cut through the ocean. Since the port and starboard were the longest sides by necessity, they could also mount the most guns, so that’s where ships tended to fight.
Starships are obviously not dealing with hydrodynamics, so they have no such requirement. A starship’s longest side can face any direction, or for that matter, a ship could have perfect symmetry with no side longer than another. If your design happens to have one side longer, it might make the most sense to mount your weapons there, simply because there’s more room to put them. So when I talk about starships doing broadside exchanges, that might look like sailing ships trading shots as they sail abreast…or it might not.
I envision capital ships mounting their weapons in multiple turrets on at least two sides, allowing them to simultaneously track targets in a complete sphere. Firing from any of the armed sides would consitute a broadside barrage.
Fighting along paired broadsides gives you practical options that you don’t have otherwise. For example, if one of the sides becomes damaged, you can roll the ship, turning a fresh side toward the enemy. You can move between enemies, fully engaging the targets with different weapons. Or, if your propulsion originates from only one side of the ship, you no longer have guns facing in only one direction relative to your acceleration.
Depending on the design of your ship, it’s even possible to pair broadsides in such a way that weapons can fire in overlapping arcs, allowing them to fight separate targets or focus together on one. To illustrate this idea, imagine a three-dimensional rectangle. Place turrets across the top of the ship, with their weapons parallel to the hull, just like a modern-day battleship. Do the same across the bottom. These weapons could pivot to fire left and right, just right, or just left. If we assume they can elevate 90 degrees and lower just a few, we cover the sphere almost perfectly. (Incidentally, I’m not proposing this as the optimal ship design — just an illustration of an idea.)
Why not use a single, big turret just like a tank? Tanks have an excellent field of fire, because their turrets allow them to shoot in a full circle, even pivoting up or down a bit. I think this leads to the erroneous belief that its turret can fire anywhere, so this must be a great idea for starships. But keep in mind the limitations of a lone turret. First, tanks are fighting on a flat plane which enemy combatants must also conform to. This simply isn’t true in space. Second, a tank is a relatively small vehicle with only one (or perhaps a handful) of primary weapons, designed to fire at (generally speaking) one target at a time.
If you can imagine a tank with multiple primary weapons and point defenses, fighting enemies and incoming warheads in a perfect sphere, you start to understand the problem. A lone tank can only cover some portion of that sphere, while its own hull would block the other half. If your ship is approached from two sides or swarmed by more nimble adversaries, you’ll have no sufficient defense.
There’s also the obvious vulnerability of having all of your guns mounted together. The history of warfare has shown us again and again that clustering vital targets in this fashion is a very bad idea. If one good shot damages that turret, the end of your ship is nigh. That may be an acceptable loss for the smaller, cheaper tank which is hardly bigger than its own turret, but there’s a reason why the Iowa class battleship doesn’t follow suit.
Mounting your weapons in a fixed pattern on one side — something like a modern fighter plane — would be even worse. In addition to your weapons all being pointed the same direction, your ship must now be pointed that way as well. Depending on your method of propulsion, you’ll be forced to repeatedly make the choice between maneuvering properly or firing weapons, and tracking your enemy will require an energy expenditure sufficient to realign your entire vessel’s mass.
The “Sniper” Exception
With credit to Citizen Joe on the forums, there’s a great example in which you might want a primary gun that isn’t mounted in the way I described. Unless we assume your turrets are of some absurd size, the best place to mount an extremely large, focused weapon is along the spine of the ship. This could potentially provide for a gun with better range, accuracy, and power than our smaller turrets would allow. You’d have all the concerns related to fixed weapons I mentioned above — not to mention concerns about powering a weapon of that magnitude — and I’d still want some additional turrets for defensive fire. But this “sniper” weapon would be an awesome force against known targets operating at a safe distance.

Apple Podcasts
Discord
Facebook
Google Play
Pandora
Patreon
RSS
SoundCloud
Spotify
Stitcher
Twitter
YouTube

I just had a thought: How much would a space combatant have to worry about Vertigo? Despite the fact that all factors of space physics need to be taken into account, we can never change that the human body relies on gravity and is built with the assumption of an up and down, including how we keep balance.
Will the space warriors of the future need to learn to deal with Vertigo, or will combat spaceship design need to adapt to a balance of incorporating the full sphere of attack while reducing the amount of spinning, twirling and twisting a ship may well have to do in a furious combat. Disoriented pilots/gunners lead to bad aim.
Without inertial dampening I don’t see there being drastic enough maneuvers to cause inner ear vertigo, the stresses on a capitol ship subjected to multiple gravities from any possible direction would make construction of the ship a nightmare. imagine building an office building with all the equipment inside need to run a company, then try to make sure everything (including the building itself) could take a couple Gs from any direction.
Visual vertigo prolly wont matter either. Weapons wouldn’t be visually fired. As we’ve seen with video games, as long as you have a stationary crosshairs or other HUD device on a screen, it doesn’t matter how much the field of view skews or corkscrews.
fighters wouldn’t be human crewed without inertial dampening. Remote Control or pure drones would dance circles around a human fighter fighting against Gs.
This is interesting to read. I’ve just finished designing a game that will hopefully address most of the problems of zero-g combat in pretty simple ways. At least, I think it basically does its job. We’ll see. I’ll keep reading, to see if there is something you come up with (Dan) that I didn’t…
The real question is why wouldn’t you use guided weapons? Considering the ranges you would be firing, any unexpected change in direction from your target would make a none guided weapon very limited.
Other issue depend heavily on your tech. Clearly if you can control gravity on a ship, G’s from maneuvering don’t matter any more.
The other issue is defenses. If you can travel through spae at realitivistic speeds, you ahve to ahve a way to limit the impact of item you hit. That same technology would make broadsides irrelevant.
That said, I respect Dan’s view and wouldn’t poo-poo a game where broadside combat was common. Just needs to be fun.
I just came across this series of blog posts and found it interesting, but I think you all are overestimating the capabilities of sensor systems.
Space, it can’t be repeated enough, is big. If you don’t know where your enemy is, your ability to identify incoming threats is nil. On the other hand, once you’ve found the enemy you can follow him precisely, negating the need for active radar (which, though great for targeting, lights you up like a Christmas tree on fire). In my opinion, space combat will resemble sub combat more than sea battles; the goal is to get the other guy before he even knows you’re there. Lasers and missiles are both well and good, but a half-brick sailing in out of nowhere can cause a hell of a lot of devastation.
@Phelps: Indeed. One of my dream projects is to make a spaceflight/submarine game based around different types of sensors, tactical differences between active and passive detection, et cetera.
I remember a movie, Dark Planet or something, that took the submarine metaphor and ran with it. The spaceship bridge set I saw wass an inky dungeon, complete with a coffee swilling commander in a military cap with “scrambled-eggs” wings and the name of the ship. No viewscreen or external cameras (likely extraneous in deep space anyway), only sensor readouts manned by specialized crewmen. Probably saved them a ton on set-building to shoot it that way too, and they had nice miniature work to make up for it.
Actually capship combat itself is one of my dream game design projects…
I have too many dream game design projects…
Great information thanks for sharing this with us.In fact in all posts of this blog their is something to learn.I wish I had found it sooner. Keep up the good work.