From the Outside – “The Stigma”
I want to talk about the stigma associated with role-playing games and how it can be a hurdle to bringing new players into the hobby.
The podcast has done an excellent job of defining this stigma and discussing how to deal with your personal “Gamer Shame”. The one aspect of it they haven’t touched on is the slippery slope concept. This is the idea that a person acknowledges their own level of geekness and is comfortable there only by being able to point out something further down the slope. An argument using this logic would sound like, “Sure I read comics, but at least I don’t play Dungeons and Dragons. Those guys are really weird.” I think most people will find that they do this to some degree if they really look closely enough at themselves. I could point to examples from the podcast talking about LARPers, but that probably isn’t the best example, because let’s face it, they really are weird.
Another aspect of the gaming stigma to explore is how it can affect new players when they experience it firsthand. The podcast has discussed gateway games and how to walk players past the stigma and get them to the table. But once they are there, if you don’t prepare them they may not be ready for the reaction of their non-gaming friends.
The first few games are key to solidifying a new player’s interest, and if they are not confident in themselves or the hobby, they could easily be shaken by the ridicule that can come from their friends, family, or significant others upon finding out about the new hobby. Anyone who has delved into the realm of geekness that we all call home has dealt with this in relation to their own hobbies. Someone new to a hobby might not be mentally ready for this or have the tools to defend against it. At this critical juncture, you don’t want anything to scare them off, but that also includes you trying to over prepare them.
So how do you get past these issues?
To get past the initial stigmas I would suggest easing them in without any pressure at all. It is a safe bet that if they are a geek in other ways, they have at least a passing curiosity about the hobby. Making sure they know where to get the information at their own pace is the best thing you can do to bring them into the hobby. At the risk of sounding like a broken record I have not seen anything that accomplishes this better than a CD of episode 115. The key though is to take it slow and be very understanding of potentially stupid questions. As mentioned before, when they are ready for a game, make it something they would be interested in. Heavy fantasy, for example, can be overwhelming for someone who is not a fan.
Getting past the peer ridicule can be a little more difficult. The level of preemptive action required for this is inversely proportional to the strength of a person’s self-confidence. For someone strong in themselves, who doesn’t worry about what others think about them, this might never be an issue at all and need not be mentioned. For someone, however, that tends to fall into trends or is worried about self-image, not bringing it up could prevent the hobby from sticking. For these people it is also helpful to keep in mind that the people who ridicule others tend to be the ones that are also the most insecure.

Apple Podcasts
Discord
Facebook
Google Play
Pandora
Patreon
RSS
SoundCloud
Spotify
Stitcher
Twitter
YouTube

I’ve never really had this problem, since I tend to not care what other people think of me.
Nice irony about the slippery slope thing: Comics > D&D > LARPing.
“People who ridicule others tend to be the ones that are the most insecure.”
Heh.
It follows the Geek Hierarchy mostly. http://www.brunching.com/images/geekchartbig.gif
I dream of a day when I can come here or listen to the cast without having a larp-bash.
The “Denny’s larp” thing is about as real as the “killing each other in the steam tunnels” nonsense. It might have happened, but it’s not a remotely realistic portrayal.
I am willing to LARP and have done a little in the past but at least I’m not this guy:
http://solarinc.org/gallery/photos/Everhate/Scan768_sized.jpg
Yeah, this was an ironic post, considering that FtB tends to stigmatize LARPing. Donnovan’s comment is right on – I’ve run LARPs and played in them, and we didn’t go near the Denny’s. I also used to eat at Denny’s a lot with geeky friends who stayed up all night, and I never saw anyone gaming there.
This is pretty classic human behavior, however. Always find a group you can marginalize, especially when you are marginalized yourself. So gamers bash on lesser gamers, and you get the craptacular discussions of “role-playing versus roll-playing” which are so completely arbitrary and pointless. It isn’t unique to gaming, but its sad wherever it crops up, and I imagine it turns people away from the hobby. Why would they want to buy into another way to get labeled? Who wants that in their life?
My first gaming group signed a pact that provided for what woud happen if any of us decided to LARP. I won’t go into the details, but we were still in High School, so you can probably guess. People like to think that they can be better than others in meaningful ways, but sadly, we don’t deviate much from the mean in practice. At least until we make some mistakes and lear from them, which is strange behavior in and of itself.
But seriously, like 99% of the LARPers I know are really freakin’ wierd.