Bonus Episode 69 – situational GMing

* (0:18) It’s just Dan and Chad today. Whatever happened to Julia?

* (3:38) Behaviors tolerated and untolerated. Organization psychology. The book, Zapp!

* (5:20) The four styles of leadership, as applied to roleplaying. Situational Leadership (with pictures or on Wikipedia or on the official site).

* (9:48) Let it be written that here, on this date, Chad said in episode 69, “It’s always better with men.” I’m sure no one will take this out of context.

* (12:12) Applying those four styles to roleplaying.

* (22:26) The importance of recognizing the phase someone is in and knowing how to respond accordingly. Revisiting the gamification of games.

* (27:52) Chad’s hatred of cell phones and his very strong feelings on Pokemon Go. Dan speaks on reading the situation and self-awareness in general.

* (35:04) Chad made an agreement, and it’s been broken. He discusses his problems with authority.

* (38:43) Consequences of the agreement.

Hosts: Chad, Dan

Comments (6)

El Mao RoflsonSeptember 28th, 2016 at 8:07 am

Chad,

Off the top of my head, I thought of a couple of ways to deal with your player phone situation.

The Technical Approach – Set your wifi to proxy to a static page reminding the players to get off their phones. Only useful if they connect to your network.

The Passive-Aggressive Approach: Have their next set of NPC interactions with obviously distracted characters. The merchant is idly playing with an item while they’re buying something and raising the price each time they interrupt him. The person that has information they need gives vague answers because she’s fidgeting with something. Make it a quest: some cabal is using these items to distract from the coming coup.

The “Art Imitates Life” approach: Every time they’re on their phone, roll to see if a pickpocket takes something off of them because of distraction. Subsequent infractions lower the DC.

The “Attack The Party Line” Method: Make random encounter tables for apps like “Facebook” and “Pokemon Go”. Ask what app they’re using. Pull up the associated table and roll for a random encounter.

The “I Can Play This Game Too” Method: If they’re on the phone, draw from a critical fail deck and text them the result.

The “Keep Your Team In Line” Method: similar to the previous, but send it to another person in the party. If the player is off the phone before you send the text, the critical fail doesn’t happen.

EricSeptember 28th, 2016 at 10:23 pm

I have the same issues with a single player and it might get to the point soon where I have to say something.

The group I gm is pretty much all over the US and one guy in Germany so it’s over roll 20, and when I get to this person, he’s been posting online on some image board, texting or just completely zoned out and then takes like two minutes to thumb through spells and make his move.

Everyone has said they’re enjoying the sessions and we’re almost two months in, so it’s not the story being bad. Just one individual in particular

PhilOfCalthSeptember 30th, 2016 at 11:15 am

Chad, I wouldn’t threaten to pack up and walk away and never GM for them again. I would threaten to pack up and play a board game for the rest of the session. Repeated sessions like this will make the game unplayable, but shouldn’t cause a group split.
With my suggestion, hopefully any animosity will be towards the person who started playing with their phone, not towards you, rather than towards the big man-child that just took all his toys and went home.

I also like El Mao’s “I Can Play This Game Too” method.

PhilOfCalthSeptember 30th, 2016 at 11:16 am

Obvious typo is obvious

NickSeptember 30th, 2016 at 7:30 pm

Chad, give the old restaurant stack-o’-phones method a crack:
Put your phone in the middle of the table, and tell people to stack their phones on top. Once the phone tower is erected, explain the rules: first person to reach over and pick up their phone pays for the pizza. The larger the group, the more costly it is to pick up the phone.

Phone is ringing? Ostensiblyl, if it’s an emergency, it’s worth the cost of a couple pizzas to answer. If it’s not an emergency, let it ring. (Someone expecting an emergency call, like impending childbirth, can set a special ringtone too, or pre-arrange a code with the would-be caller. A friend of mine had one set up with his mom when his dad was in poor health: if her ringtone rings once, goes quiet for 30s, and then rings again, pick it up. If it just rings long from the start, it’s just a dinner invite or lawn care request or something.

You could take it a step further and go penalty box: whoever reaches in first has to actually get up, leave the table (and house) and go for a beer run. Their character misses out on XP/loot, they have to pay for the beer, and there is invariably a lot of teasing. In-game cost + economic cost + social cost = effective corrective strategy.

Leoff/Shannon DicksonOctober 2nd, 2016 at 2:32 pm

Dan and Chad, you guys are just too nice. The steam roller is your friend. El Mao’s “Art Imitates Life” method is good, but I wouldn’t even bother making the roll to see whether something happens; I’d just let something happen and make a note of it. On a whiteboard, in view of everyone who’s paying attention, but it’d happen. “In the midst of the chaos, J’s character Thudbjorn drops his Cure Light Wounds bandolier.” “A crewman sticks his head in and says, “oh, Tom’s-character-Sparky, someone broke your tricorder.” And I’d have a stack of pink post-its, with “-1 to Wis” handy and just drop them on appropriate character sheets, and just carry on with the action. They can keep up if they want.

Leave a comment

Your comment