Episode 405 – RPGs and mental health, part 1

* (0:39) Mental health as a topic, why we’re talking about it, and some important disclaimers.

* (8:49) Why this relates so closely to gaming.

* (13:47) Dan’s history and issues.

* (18:41) The uniqueness of the conditions when compared to “normal” thoughts. The courage of getting treatment.

* (26:04) The anatomy of a panic attack.

* (27:24) PTSD can come from any serious trauma.

* (28:54) Brodeur’s history and issues.

* (32:47) The anatomy of PTSD.

* (34:39) Wayne’s history and issues.

* (38:03) Medication as a way to get a handle on an issue.

* (40:13) Time does not heal all wounds, but there are ways to cope. The Anxiety & Phobia Workbook.

* (46:22) Advice to people that know someone suffering from a mental disorder.

Hosts: Brodeur, Chris, Dan, Wayne

Comments (15)

Ursus MaritimusJune 23rd, 2016 at 12:15 pm

Wow. Wow. Cajones of adamantium, gentleman. Excellent handling of an incredibly delicate topic. No doubt you have done a great service for many people.

DanJune 23rd, 2016 at 12:18 pm

Thank you! We figured this was a topic that needed to be talked about. Part 2 is coming next week, and we’ve already got a show in early planning where we’re going to talk about using games as a tool of therapy.

markJune 23rd, 2016 at 1:26 pm

Saw this as a retweet and wasn’t expecting much. Absolutely fantastic job.

WayneJune 23rd, 2016 at 2:28 pm

I am glad to hear that it is being taken as we intended.

JohnJune 23rd, 2016 at 2:59 pm

Hey guys,

Working on anxiety issues myself, and like you guys it came on worst in my early 20s. To clarify I get anxiety attacks vs. panic attacks. The difference is that I know that I am not going to die (as is the case for panic attacks) and instead fear that something bad is going to happen unless I get the “situation” under control, even if that situation is imagined (anxiety attack.) I too skipped the drug option and went to a doctor who was exceptional for me and worked through Behavior Therapy to fix it up. I will always wrestle with it though have lots of tools now to work on it with. It comes with depression and I always have to keep a level head to get through day to day and understand that I’m not perfect, and mess ups are OK. That took practice too. Getting on a subway where I didn’t know if it was an express, a local or even in the direction I needed to go. Getting into a situation where I’m going to be unable to get out of for over an hour. Just saying yes to a situation without overthinking. Lots of triggers, just that much practicing opportunity!

Fortunately I’m fine without meds, it just takes hard work and constant practice. My job helps due to the “armor” of my job, but also because it can be incredibly random and pushes me hard to overcome my anxiety triggers. I also put on the “armor” of overworking, have a wonderfully supportive wife, and the whole lot. What a relief this podcast is.

Some books I found useful were; The Happiness Trap by Russ Harris As well as Don’t Panic by Reid Wilson

PatrickJune 23rd, 2016 at 6:59 pm

I just wanted to thank you guys for being so open, so honest and so eloquent in describing your struggles with mental illness. I have suffered from undiagnosed (for most of my life) and more recently, diagnosed chronic PTSD.

It is a problem that I wouldn’t wish upon my worst enemy, but it always feels somewhat cathartic to hear my peers discuss their challenges and struggles with mental illness in the cold light of day (or in this case, on a podcast).

Tremendous respect for the way you treated the subject, which is a very delicate one for many, many people…

Cautiously PessimisticJune 24th, 2016 at 2:14 pm

Hey, guys. Wanted to thank you for the topic discussion. I’ve had to deal with depression going on 35 years now (since onset of puberty). Ate the elephant one bite at a time until I was able to get on SSRIs in my mid twenties. In that golden age, I learned what normal people felt like, and more importantly, learned how to mimic their behavior. Unfortunately, my body is devious about developing a tolerance for medications, and after cycling through the available SSRIs over the course of a decade, I tried some other meds that did a number on my personality and ability to cope\fake it. After a couple of years of that, I made the decision to forgoe meds altogether. It’s not pleasant, but it provides better stability. Eating the elephant for the better part of twenty years has given me the chance to develop coping mechanisms ranging from alcoholism, to religion, to increasing my odds of recognizing and pulling out of destructive thought cycles before I stop wanting to do so. My penultimate aim in life is to die of something other than suicide, and I think at this point I have a decent shot at it. Blah blah blah.
As for gaming, though I have great difficulty being much more than a shut in, I did play RPGs growing up, and use the various podcasts and actual plays to keep me socially stimulated when I can’t deal with people in realtime. So thanks for that. Additionally, when out and about not running away screaming from people, I can’t help but feel like my previous role playing experience helps out. It’s as close as I got to acting.
Thanks for the discussion topic. After part two, how about y’all talk about something a bit lighter? Find a way to work in the phrase “tree weasel” for bonus points.

DanJune 24th, 2016 at 4:27 pm

CP – We’re definitely going to do something lighter after part 2. While I think this is an important topic and needed to be hit, it’s not what we want the show to become about from this point forward.

ChrisJune 27th, 2016 at 4:43 pm

I just wanted to jump in and say “thank you” for this episode. I relate to so much here. I don’t want to write out all my past troubles here, but starting in ’98 I’ve been dealing with depression, anxiety, emotional/mental abuse, and I got really good at pushing things down to just keep going until things started falling apart about eight years ago. At that point, I started having panic attacks, and more recently it cumulated in some very long nights of suicidal thoughts that thankfully never resulted in action, but it took all of my energy to not self-harm more than I did (some minor, non-marking stuff). I felt like I didn’t deserve help, couldn’t see things for what they were, couldn’t figure out why anyone would even associate with me let alone like me. Depression lies and it can be very hard to see through that, and even when you can, it’s hard to even care.

The short of it is I logically recognized it for what it was and finally got a therapist, and then more recently a “whole picture” type doctor (GP) that’s giving me vitamin B shots and put me on a regime of less-harsh herbs designed to help my body process seratonin better. In the mean time, I’ve had to cut out everything I used to love doing, partially because of social anxiety, and partially because of the cost of my emotional and mental energies. No in-person gaming, no fencing class, no beer-brewing with friends, very seldomly even leaving my apartment for anything but work and the grocery store. It’s been hard, because it’s hard not to feel completely lazy. I feel lucky I have a therapist who actually supports this and realizes with my introverted tendencies, this is how I heal – I withdraw and do my socializing online. Anything else just takes too much mental energy. The good news is, yesterday I went and did something social on my own for the first time in almost a year, and it felt pretty awesome.

I’m not delusional enough to think I’m out of the dark yet, but things are headed on the right path, and that’s encouraging. So again, I really, really appreciate hearing all of your experiences and know that there are others who can relate and I’m not so different or weird from other people.

DanJune 29th, 2016 at 10:16 am

You mentioned several things I can relate to, but there’s one thing in particular I want to comment on. If I remember right, it’s not discussed in 405, but it does get mentioned in 406. It’s the idea of a shrinking world. Over time, it feels like the emotional toll of dealing with people builds up higher and higher, and the anxiety/depression makes it harder to cope even in the best of times.

When you start to withdraw a bit, you become anxious about how that’s going to affect the way people view you. Do they understand why I’m not here? Will they stop inviting me to activities? Are they gossiping about me? And in some cases it’s, unfortunately, quite true.

It’s something I’ve really been struggling with over the past few years. My world shrinks a little bit every day, and the actions of some people only magnify those anxieties and keep my world shrinking. It just starts to feel safer and easier to be alone than to take the risks to see even just a small number of people. I’m not saying that’s the right or healthy way to handle the anxiety, but it’s how things often play out.

ZeroJuly 2nd, 2016 at 8:38 pm

A little late to the game, but I wanted to chime in and say this is a great episode that exceeded expectations. Thank you for sharing.

I wanted to mention that very early on in the episode Brodeur mentions not being one of those “Safe Space people”. While I understand the sentiment, safe spaces look different for everyone, and that sort of commentary is contributing to the type of stigma this episode is trying to erode. While the Safe Space concept is a current favorite punching bag in the media, It’s very hard to judge folks who are abusing the concept of a safe space from folks who genuinely need that space and have a right to ask for it without being one of those people who stigmatize folks with mental health issues. For some people, knowing there is a safe group they can be with is much more useful than going to a psychiatrist/psychologist. This is often the power of things like veteran support groups, AA and NA, and LGBT “Families”.

That being said, this episode went a long way towards breaking down that barrier, and I am likely to put this on my list to share with even my non-gamer friends, as this stuff can be hard to describe and y’all did a great job of keeping it simple. I do not want to imply one unfortunate set of phrasing made this great episode “bad” in some way. Thanks for the excellent free content, as always ^.^

AngelJuly 3rd, 2016 at 9:50 pm

Thank you for this.

I’ve been dealing with anxiety issues since I was at least 5 years old, depressive episodes and suicide attempts in my teens, PTSD from a sexual assault, and started having both panic and anxiety attacks in my twenties. As it turns out, my predilection towards mood disorders is actually a symptom of Asperger’s that went undiagnosed until I was almost thirty.

For those of you with friends and family dealing with mental health issues, here are a few things you can say that I’ve personally found helpful:
I love/care about you.
I’m here to listen if you want to talk about anything.
If you need help, I’m here.

GregJuly 9th, 2016 at 1:32 am

I’ve been grazing around the podcast landscape looking for a good show about RPG’s. And despite your entreaties not to make the mental health episode my first experience with the show, it was. I am now all-in with you guys. As a gamer who suffers from both depression and anxiety, I was floored to hear a gamer show tackle the subject at all, let alone in such a sensitive and intelligent way. I couldn’t hit the subscribe button fast enough. Thanks so much for this, and I can’t wait to listen to some of your “normal” business now.

JamesJuly 20th, 2016 at 8:47 am

Long time silent listener.
It means a lot to hear about issues close to my heart and that of my friends.
Thanks for sharing this with us and for treating the matter with respect and without preaching.
This has made my day.

PaulAugust 8th, 2016 at 4:51 pm

An excellent couple of episodes. Thanks for making this episode. Big thank you for sharing your stories too. Look forward to more episodes like this.

Leave a comment

Your comment