Episode 234 – themes
* (0:30) Battletech, the map case, and why we’re hesitant to let certain people play characters of another gender.
* (5:24) The start of the next March of Dimes charity auction. You have 10 days to bid on a complete Dresden Files set with a GM book, several player books, and plenty of Fudge dice. The books will all be signed by Fred Hicks, Rob Donoghue, and the Fear the Boot hosts. If you wish to make a donation apart from the auction, you can do so here.
* (8:08) Themes we’d like to see more often — or never again — in roleplaying games. Topics discussed include romance, evil, mercenaries, redemption, addiction, friendship, moral complexity, tragic endings, ambiguous endings, discovery, world context, and the single-dimension quest.
Hosts: Chad, Chris, Dan, Pat, Wayne
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | RSS

Apple Podcasts
Discord
Facebook
Google Play
Pandora
Patreon
RSS
SoundCloud
Spotify
Stitcher
Twitter
YouTube

An interesting episode, but I have one complaint:
I’ve heard many good reasons why men shouldn’t play female characters, but the one you gave is stupid. A female friend of mine once smuggled cannabis by hiding it exactly where the PC in your Battletech group hid the map. Could it be that your picture of women is somewhat better than reality?
I have no delusion that women can be imperfect or outright sleazy. I’ve heard similar stories about women using their privates to mule drugs, prison contraband, and a variety of other things. So in a panic, is hiding a map case there completely implausible? No, probably not. But that didn’t occur in a vacuum, either. I realize we didn’t give all of the context on the show, but that was a sort of “pinnacle” act in that character being consistently played in really degrading ways.
Dan, I’ve heard a lot about how males playing female characters is bad. But I’ve not heard much about the other way around.
What are some reasons why females should not play male characters?
Good question. I confess ignorance, as I simply haven’t seen it done. Every female I’ve gamed with has generally played female characters.
Regarding playing out addiction as a roleplaying only exercise, I think the problem is that it becomes simply a yes/no with only personal consequences. Will the character succumb today or not? It seems like it’s up to the whim of the player, and how interesting that would be at the time. Which is completely unlike addiction.
I think a mechanical push adds that stress that a player would not really put upon themselves. Not just a purely random coin flip for ‘yes, you succumb’, but you can imagine that each day you roll your DC. If you fail, the magnitide is the penalty you take for the day on a number of significant other rolls. However, for each long period of time you abstain (say a month) you can reduce the DC to a certain floor value, perhaps even lowering that floor per game year to a minimal DC eventually.
Meanwhile, any time the character succumbs, all penalties instantly disappear, yet the DC raises by an increment for each shorter period of time. And over an very extended period of time (each year) perhaps there is a character degeneration.
It seems to me you do need the random element to add an unpredictable element. To ensure challenges can come at the worst of times that don’t result in player conflict (why now when you happily ignored it beofre?) . And the mechanical penalties and resolutions add a conflict for the player themselves – a short term mitigation that had longer term consequences, and a real penalty to RP against for staying strong on a day when the penalties are quite severe. That sort of player choices and long term goal that might not seem worth it during each short term encounter would fall in to step perfectly with what the charatcer is going through.
Just a thought!
Easy fix for romance in-game: instead of having the PCs role play with other PCs or the GM, the Time Cube bot plays the part of the love interest.
Common sense solutions, people.