Episode 220 – players taking NPCs

* (0:29) Fear the Boot raises a glass to Willie.

* (3:07) RPG tropes we individually find annoying or overused.  Plus counterpoints on why each one may not be so bad.

* (27:59) Jumping into an NPC as a way of staying involved and adding color to a scene.  We focus on the implicit player-GM contract, when it’s appropriate (or not), what it can add to the game, and how much plot leverage you should grant yourself while doing it.

Hosts: Chad, Dan, Johann, Pat, Wayne

NOTE: If you hear some clicking during a couple minutes in the middle of the show, that was an issue with our audio setup.  Nothing is wrong with your download or MP3 player, and it ends a few minutes after it starts.

Comments (10)

DragonhelmFebruary 4th, 2011 at 2:46 pm

I find it funny how Chad dislikes some of the settings I like. I think Shadowrun is a nifty idea and I love me some Spelljammer. Giant space hamsters for the win!

I have to agree that L5R is a great setting with a lot of good story potential. There are a few more archetypes to play in the d20 version. My problem with the game is that it tries to be a bit too historically correct for my tastes. I hate how obeying your daimyo and saving face take precedent over doing the right thing. Personally, I like a little heroism in my games, one of the problems I have with Shadowrun.

SandpunkFebruary 4th, 2011 at 3:44 pm

Dear Wayne,
Wierd West has been around far longer than that, and while I agree that WWW wasn’t the best example, Wierd West can and has been awesome.

DragonhelmFebruary 4th, 2011 at 11:46 pm

Oh, and as for the monk…it’s fantasy! If we took out everything in D&D that wasn’t western European, the game would be a lot more barren. No minotaur, no medusa. If those are okay, then why is a monk not?

Okay, I say that Chad and I fight in a big pool of jello at Fear the Con. We sell tickets and donate the proceeds to charity. Or we could get a couple of hot chicks to fight as our champions while Chad and I watch. ;-)

Just messin’ with ya, Chad!

MichaelFebruary 5th, 2011 at 11:01 pm

What kind of scotch was it?

NathanFebruary 9th, 2011 at 4:08 pm

Quick correction for Chad,

In L5R the Unicorn clan is modeled after the Mongols and not Western Knights – so they still fit the Asian theme.

Dan NFebruary 11th, 2011 at 3:51 pm

Ice! They’re having it with ice?!!! :-]

DanFebruary 16th, 2011 at 5:36 pm

@Dragonhelm – I think the distinction I would make regarding monks is that Greece is both culturally and geographically much closer to western Europe than Zhengzhou, China is. Heck, some historians refer to western culture all the way up to today as a “footnote” of Greek culture. I have to imagine you’d be much more likely to find someone in 12th century England that knew of minotaurs than, say, Kimnara King.

@Michael – It was Cutty Sark, if I’m not mistaken. It was definitely a harsh drink, but I was honored to participate in Johann’s tradition of honoring his friend.

LomythicaFebruary 22nd, 2011 at 10:19 am

As for genres, it seems that a genre is taking reality, then adding a ‘how would it affect the world if element X existed, or was somehow more or less prominent.

Fantasy – What if magic worked, dragons existed, etc.

Scifi – Numerous different possibilities

The way I think of it, is in the idea of ‘X’ being a miracle. In Fantasy, the Miracle is that magic exists in some form. From there, how would it change the world if magic exists? Suddenly, magical oriented creatures could exist, superstition about magic may (or may not) be decreased since people experience it more openly.

So, genre mashups are just take miracles that are associated with specific genres, and put them into the same world. Personally, it doesn’t appeal to me as much as some, but I can understand that people may like the idea.

LomythicaFebruary 22nd, 2011 at 10:49 am

When I hand a player to play an NPC, i try to give them a motivation and any info they will need. Of course, this requires more time. NPC takeover is generally for shorter scenes, and the power of the NPC that I would offer to be played, depends on the trust between GM and player.

I read recently from some play posts of a guy taking an improv class. One rule of improv.. Never say no.

Find a way to build whatever it is in. If the guard says Orcs are coming, but they aren’t.. Maybe a stampede of horses comes galloping toward the party. Keep in mind that an NPC has limited knowledge, so a GM that hands out an NPC can always cover that the NPC had bad info. Of course any valuable info should be given to the player before they take on the NPC role.

LomythicaFebruary 22nd, 2011 at 10:57 am

Wow.. so many great points!

I measure how long roleplay should go on based on the purpose of the scene. If roleplay is occuring and it pertains to moving toward the goal of the scene or developing the plot at hand, then it can go on as needed.

When roleplay becomes flavortext, or isn’t moving the story forward, it probably shouldn’t go on very long IMHO. I don’t mind flavortexting characters with roleplay, but I find that roleplay with conflict is far more interesting.. Especially if you have ‘That guy’ that jumps in for every scene whether it is necessary or not.

Leave a comment

Your comment