Video Games and Role Playing
Back before the days of Ultima and Everquest, role playing games were known amongst players as a “do anything you want, be what you want to be” form of entertainment. Within the boundaries of the system, players could become ancient warriors, mystical wizards, or cunning rogues. But when Ultima Online came out in the mid nineties, RPGs were no longer limited to the table. Players could team up with friends, battle foes, and pursue epic storylines in hopes of fame and fortune.
Fast forward to the emergence of “Sandbox RPGs” and the global popularity of “Massively Multiplayer Online Role Playing Games.” Open and “do what you want” gameplay is the standard. So where does that leave rpg’s? Tabletop rpg’s helped influence the first video games, and now in some cases, video games are influencing tabletop rpg’s. An excellent example of a MMORPG inspired rule system is the fourth edition of Dungeons and Dragons, and more specifically, its power system.
MMORPG’s standardized method of giving all the players activatable powers that will do everything from swinging a sword to casting a spell makes using the interface simple, and quick. Dungeons and Dragons took a page out of this book and made all character abilities “powers”, making it easier for players to pick up new classes (because they didn’t have to learn how a magic system worked), but still kept the classes unique.
Another example is from more free form video games, like Morrowind, and their effects on games such as Savage Worlds. In Morrowind, while initial stat choices will have a major influence on how well you do certain tasks, the system allows you to still develop skill in other areas. Fighters can cast magic, Wizards can wear heavy armor, Morrowind’s rule system allows for full customization, given a little time. Savage Worlds does similar things with its own system. Through gained experience, characters expand their skills in any field they want, there is no restriction of a “class” system.
Now lets discuss the influences on the actual stories. I consider my gaming streak to be a colorful one, and one common trait I have found in most games is that there is a Morrowind style of plot development. While the entire campaign is “open” to the players, there always seems to be one major plot that the characters are meant to follow. When the players break away, the missions tend to be briefer and easier to accomplish. This may predate Morrowind, or even video games, but this has certainly become increasingly popular as more people claim to be “Sandbox GMs”. Another variation of the typical “Sandbox GM” is more of a MMORPG style of games, very brief quests with no larger plot arcs to be seen.
So what does all of this mean to the respective hobbies? I have only been playing long enough to get a glimpse of the pre-MMORPG era, but I think that tabletop games have gained many improvements from their video game counterparts, and have made cousins in the geek culture. As technology becomes increasingly sophisticated, we may continue to see ground breaking concepts come up that can be readily harvested for the tabletop community.

Apple Podcasts
Discord
Facebook
Google Play
Pandora
Patreon
RSS
SoundCloud
Spotify
Stitcher
Twitter
YouTube

Morrowind definitely wasn’t the first CRPG, nor the first RPG that allowed initial stat choices to influence but not constrict character growth. The d6 system by West End Games was one of the first that I know of that allowed that sort of customization (iirc – that was back in the mid ’80s)
Wasteland was also a CRPG that allowed characters to diverge from their initial stat choices. It’s cousin Fallout has continued that trend. The latest version of which is indeed made by Morrowind’s developers.
It’s a thought provoking article, and I wanted to add a bit more history to your lesson. Thanks, and keep writing.
I have to disagree with you on MMOs having “Open and “do what you want” gameplay.” Having played at least 10 MMOs, do what you want is almost never an option in MMOs. You do what the game designers want. Ranging from killing monsters, completing quests, raids and pvp. There is almost no ability to make new objectives, new types of gameplay or, to be honest, even any fun quests. (kill 10x rats, collect 10x rat toes, and sometimes kill 10x rats AND collect 10x rat toes)
Modern MMOs are tredmills, designed to keep players interested in a single campaign as long as possible. ($15 a month!) MMOs will never have the breadth and width of a single player CRPG, and no CRPG will ever allow players to have options like those available in PnP games.
What technology will allow, someday, is for games like Everquest, WoW, ect, to read characters movements and intentions to allow new game elements to be created without any programmer input. But until this day, MMOs and CRPGs will always take 2nd place to pencil and paper, in terms of unlimited options to the players.
Michael,
you need to look more into the prehistory of tabletop RPGs, and not just look at Dungeons and Dragons. Games such as Runequest and Traveller which are from the 70s never had classes and had skills-based systems.
IMO, Having played some MMORPGs, enjoyable as they are apart from the graphics and the number of players, they don’t really add anything to the tabletop experience and in many ways are far more limited than a tabletop RPG. In fact, MMORPGs really haven’t progressed with what was done with MUDs in the late 80s and early 90s, eye-candy excluded.
Thank you for all commenting. This article was written as an observation, not a comprehensive history for the two areas.
-Michael
Yes, look back on MUDs, I would suggest that MUDs sometimes exceeded the capabilities of even current day MMOs due to dedicated GMs (known as “Gods” or “Immortals” in MUDs) who would script specific features into the game as needed to make the environment for flexible, and to create quests or plot lines with personal oversight.
Of course the advantage of MUDs were that they did not have such a massive playerbase with most having no more than 30 players online at any one time.
I would say the modern-day versions of MUDs are actually games like Neverwinter Nights rahter than MMOs which are on a whole different scale.
— Pete.
This all about the taste and history, everyone looked a better side of the game by the taste and not too bothered that it is not he taste