Okay so with a vote you each count for half the crew with only two of you that means you gotta sway one to your side or it gonna come to a fight.

Handsome Jack has a bargain on the table: Back off and you'll see some sport.

Your options are: Make a bargain/compromise, or make a move(either on Reed or the other player)

So long as blood is spilt I'm happy

That sounds like a compromise, Jack will hand The Celt a cat o' nine tails and stand way back.

Do we know how to build morale or what? It's almost like a company picnic!

I wouldn't be surprised if there were company picnics just like this. Nudge nudge wink wink say no more

Okay rolled a Brutality vs. Soul for The Celt attacking the helpless. Got 4 vs. 1 (2-1) so it succeeds. Which means Reed gets his beating, no fighting back or jumping overboard. Also The Celt gets 3 more Xs putting him at 6.

Did you guys want to do something during the lashing? Do you want to beat him till he's dead or are you going to stop it after every man gets a turn(80-100 lashes depending on how many extra lashes the officers take) and do something else to him? If you're not doing anything i'll just describe the beating and we'll move on from there.

I rolled for The Resolute showing up during the beating, it was a 6.

Griffsnog do you mind if I post your Stats on the wiki so that I have a quick way to reference them

Is that good or bad?

Neither. But the next time I roll for it, if I roll a six again it shows up.

I have no objection stats are just numbers.

If he survives the lashes it is up to the crew really. The Celt will not object to a gutting, keelhaul, or beheading. Jack may want to have a look over him first though and determine if he can survive another round of floggings.