The creators of the show decided to remove her after they learned why the fans named her "Derpy" and that it came from a derogatory term for mentally disabled people.
The PUBLISHERS of the show bowed down to pressure from iTunes when someone convinced iTunes that "Derpy" was a derogatory term. Since iTunes hosts the shows for internet sales, they didn't have much choice.
Sat Jun 30, 2012 9:27 pm
Azhrei Vep
Loves a Zinger
Joined: Fri Nov 20, 2009 5:44 pm Posts: 17953 Location: Sitting in Judgement from the Oval Office
Re: Ponies
Viletta Vadim wrote:
Either way, they gave Derpy Hooves a speaking part and actually made her name canon. I'm more than happy with that.
Then they edited the episode to change her name and and voice. Not too happy with that.
_________________
Chad wrote:
Let me tell you some things I don't do: I don't do Women. - FtB, Ep88, 36:46
Your Vorpal Sword uses Behead!... It's super effective!
Sat Jun 30, 2012 11:20 pm
werefrog
Chad's Second Copy
Joined: Sun Aug 17, 2008 9:57 pm Posts: 7789 Location: The Pad
Re: Ponies
Azhrei Vep wrote:
Viletta Vadim wrote:
Either way, they gave Derpy Hooves a speaking part and actually made her name canon. I'm more than happy with that.
Then they edited the episode to change her name and and voice. Not too happy with that.
Neither am The Werefrog.
it's like that episode of South Park in which Timmy joins The Lords of the Underworld. All the adults were protesting the band because it was just using the mentally disabled kid, but Timmy made the music good. He was that thing the band was missing. They kept telling the kids who liked it they should feel bad because they were making Timmy feel bad. Stan responds, "He looks pretty happy to me."
Also, there is no term for retarded, mentally disabled, special education, etc. people that isn't derogatory, or that won't be considered derogatory within 4 years. As such, Derpy Hooves is a perfectly good name. She deserves to be a part of the show as she was designed by the fandom.
_________________ Heus, modo itera omnia quae mihi nunc nuper narravisti, sed nunc Anglice?
Timespike wrote:
You KILLED A DRAGON with a Daze spell? You are full of awesome and win!
Itunes has a lot at stake. Even the implied threat of bad publicity will make a huge impact on sales. So they are erring on the side of vanilla caution. A background character on a kid's cartoon isn't worth it. And Bronies have a reputation of rolling over and taking it (love and tolerance). So there won't be any financial backlash for yielding to Itunes. There are two versions of that episode, one with Derpy and the other sanitized through Itunes. The fans have both and get some sort of hipster cred for having seen both.
Sun Jul 01, 2012 6:58 am
Azhrei Vep
Loves a Zinger
Joined: Fri Nov 20, 2009 5:44 pm Posts: 17953 Location: Sitting in Judgement from the Oval Office
Re: Ponies
Morgan_Lockbreaker wrote:
Azhrei Vep wrote:
Viletta Vadim wrote:
Either way, they gave Derpy Hooves a speaking part and actually made her name canon. I'm more than happy with that.
Then they edited the episode to change her name and and voice. Not too happy with that.
Which episode was this? I've only seen through season 2.
Season 2 is all there is, as far as I know. I can't recall the episode name (and i'm not in the mood to hit wikipedia at the moment), but it's the episode where Applejack takes off for some rodeo and doesn't come back because she didn't win. Had a great I love Lucy bit in it.
Derpy had a named speaking role in the intro segment, and it pissed some people off because they considered it ableist (the word 'Derpy' is apparently a derogatory term for retarded people, and she had a thick voice that could be considered vaguely reminiscent of some handicap or other, I can't remember which), so it got edited to Ditzy instead of Derpy (insulting term for airheaded women! Much better!) and they fixed the eyes and voice.
It was mildly annoying, kicked up a brief shitstorm that was even more annoying, and has since been mostly put to bed, as far as I can tell.
_________________
Chad wrote:
Let me tell you some things I don't do: I don't do Women. - FtB, Ep88, 36:46
Chad wrote:
Oh my god, I love the Boys! FtB, Ep144, 35:05
PS. Fuck you Cafepress
Sun Jul 01, 2012 7:17 am
werefrog
Chad's Second Copy
Joined: Sun Aug 17, 2008 9:57 pm Posts: 7789 Location: The Pad
Joined: Wed Mar 18, 2009 5:02 am Posts: 1326 Location: Netherlands
Re: Ponies
Azhrei Vep wrote:
I can't recall the episode name (and i'm not in the mood to hit wikipedia at the moment), but it's the episode where Applejack takes off for some rodeo and doesn't come back because she didn't win.
The Last Roundup.
Citizen Joe wrote:
The PUBLISHERS of the show bowed down to pressure from iTunes when someone convinced iTunes that "Derpy" was a derogatory term. Since iTunes hosts the shows for internet sales, they didn't have much choice.
Hasbro & The Hub made that call after they got emails complaining about how the name Derpy and her portrayal was offensive to them. iTunes didn't have anything to with the decision making process here. At least I haven't found anything to indicated they did. No clue how many complaints were send, but the person credited for writing the episode - Amy Keating Rogers - has come forward and said she got about 10 complaints.
Personally, I am kinda suprised someone got worked up over Derpy and - as far as I know - noone complained about Zecora.
_________________ Nine out of ten science frogs say any mistake in grammar and/or spelling in the above post is merely a figment of your imagination.
Mon Jul 02, 2012 2:49 am
werefrog
Chad's Second Copy
Joined: Sun Aug 17, 2008 9:57 pm Posts: 7789 Location: The Pad
Re: Ponies
What's wrong with Zecora?
_________________ Heus, modo itera omnia quae mihi nunc nuper narravisti, sed nunc Anglice?
Timespike wrote:
You KILLED A DRAGON with a Daze spell? You are full of awesome and win!
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum